I don’t know why I’m obsessed with people hating on minimalist and barefoot running, but I am. I guess I’m obsessed with people hating on anything really. I believe in very few absolutes, and one of them surely is not running shoes. The fact is there are many runners out there who say their injuries have gone down since using minimalist shoes. And who am I to argue with personal experience?
According to this opinion piece in the Boston Globe, barefoot shoes (Vibrams specifically) make you feel a “giddy lightness” at first but, unfortunately, that feeling comes with a price. The author recounts all the perils he experienced as he trained for and eventually ran a half marathon in his Vibram Five Fingers. He goes on and on about how much it hurt, but as the race neared he decided to wear the Vibrams because he figured he had adapted enough to them, and he didn’t have any injuries yet.
What strikes me about the story is that he admits, even as he was adapting to the shoes, that he couldn’t shake a “persistent pain in the bridge” of his foot. Yet he ran the half marathon anyway. By the end of the race, he had a stress fracture in his foot and was ordered to lay off running for six weeks.
The lesson I take away from this is that it’s important to listen to your body. I have no doubt that there are runners out there who run through the pain (I know I have), but we have to be smart. If minimalist or barefoot shoes hurt you more than your regular running shoes, don’t be a martyr! If they make you feel good, I say go for it. Stop the hate. Make love, not war.


